How to Learn From Your Mistakes on Practice Tests
Sort every wrong answer by its cause, keep a mistake log you actually reopen and retest on a schedule: a review routine that works for any practice test.
On this page
In short
- Review a practice test within 24 hours. Retry each wrong or blank question before you read the solution, then sort every mistake by cause: knowledge gap, misconception, misreading, careless slip, timing or guess.
- Write each correction in your own words in a mistake log, with a signal for next time, and redo those questions a few days and about a week later without the answers.
- Track which kinds of mistakes cost you points across several tests, not just the total score.
Most of what a practice test can teach you comes from the review afterward, so review it within 24 hours. Before you read any solution, try each wrong or blank question again on your own. Then sort every mistake by its cause (a knowledge gap, a misconception, a misread question, a careless slip, a timing problem or a guess), write the correction in your own words in a mistake log, and redo those questions a few days and about a week later without looking at the answers.
If you only mark a test and move on, you throw away most of what it could tell you. Two students with the same score can need very different fixes: one never learned the formula, while the other knows it and keeps dropping minus signs. The score alone can't show that difference; the review can.
This guide covers what to do after the test. For how retrieval practice and spaced review work in general, read active recall and spaced repetition.
Why reviewing your mistakes works
Taking a test is itself a way of learning. Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke (2006) had students read short science passages and then either reread them or take a recall test. On a final test five minutes later, rereading came out slightly ahead. Two days and a week later, the students who had been tested remembered more, even though they got no feedback on their first test. A 2021 meta-analysis by Chunliang Yang and colleagues pooled 222 classroom studies with 48,478 students and found that quizzing raised achievement by a medium amount. How much it helped depended on several things, including whether students received corrective feedback and how many times they were tested.
A failed attempt still does some work. Nate Kornell, Matthew Hays and Robert Bjork (2009) wrote questions people were sure to miss, including made-up trivia such as "What peace treaty ended the Calumet War?" People who tried to answer before seeing the answer learned it better than people who simply read the question and answer together, although every one of those attempts failed. The hard question you got wrong on a practice test can still teach you something, as long as you find out the right answer afterward. These were lab tasks with word pairs and trivia, so read the result as a reason to try before you peek. It makes no promise about exam scores.
Confident errors turn out to be the easiest to fix. Brady Butterfield and Janet Metcalfe (2001) asked people how sure they were of each answer. The errors made with high confidence were the ones most likely to be corrected on a later retest, which went against what the authors expected. In her 2017 review, Metcalfe concluded that making errors and then getting corrective feedback helps learning, and that the feedback should include an analysis of the reasoning that led to the mistake. She also suggests making and correcting errors in low-stakes settings before a high-stakes exam, which is what a practice test gives you.
Right answers you weren't sure about need attention too. Andrew Butler, Jeffrey Karpicke and Henry Roediger (2008) found that feedback doubled how well people retained correct answers they had given with low confidence.
Feedback helps most when it tells you what to do next. John Hattie and Helen Timperley (2007) described useful feedback as answering three questions: Where am I going? How am I going? Where to next? Praise was among the least effective forms in the studies they summarized. A 2020 meta-analysis by Benedikt Wisniewski, Klaus Zierer and John Hattie (435 studies, more than 61,000 people) found a medium effect of feedback on learning overall, and feedback that carried a lot of information worked far better than simple rewards or punishments. A red mark on a test only says you were wrong. Your review has to work out why, and what you will do differently.
A review form doesn't do that work by itself. In one course with 86 students, Raechel Soicher and Regan Gurung (2017) tested "exam wrappers", short reflection sheets handed out after exams, and found no improvement in exam scores, final grades or a questionnaire measure of metacognition. Writing down what went wrong only pays off when it changes how you study and you test yourself again.
Sort every mistake by type
Before you fix anything, name what went wrong. Six types cover almost every lost point:
| Type | How you recognize it | How to fix it |
|---|---|---|
| Knowledge gap | You read the solution and realize you never learned this | Go back to the topic, then do 10–20 questions on it that week |
| Misconception | You were confident, and the rule or idea you used is wrong | Write the wrong idea and the right one side by side; find two questions where the difference matters |
| Misreading | You answered a different question: you missed "not", "except", the units or "which is greatest" | Underline the question words before you solve; reread the question before you mark an answer |
| Careless slip | You knew the method but dropped a sign, copied a number wrong or filled in the wrong bubble | Note your personal slip pattern and add a ten-second check for it |
| Timing | You could have solved it but ran out of time, or sat on one question too long | Practice a skip rule: mark the question, move on, come back on a second pass |
| Guess | You got it right or wrong, but you didn't really know | Treat it as a knowledge gap or misconception until you can explain the answer |
Two habits keep the sorting honest. Decide the type after you read the solution, because "careless" is the most popular label and often the wrong one. If you would make the same slip again tomorrow, it is a pattern and needs a fix. Also mark guesses while you take the test, with a small "?" next to the question, since afterward you won't remember which right answers were luck.
A question you misread under time pressure has two causes; log both. Math mistakes, from sign errors to picking the wrong method, have their own table in how to study math.
How to keep a mistake log
A mistake log (also called an error log or wrong-answer notebook) records what you learned from each mistake; you don't need to copy out every question you missed. Each entry has four parts:
- The question in brief: subject, topic, source and question number, or a photo. You need enough to find it and redo it.
- Why you got it wrong: the type from the table and one sentence about what happened.
- The right way: the key step or idea, in your own words. Don't copy the answer key.
- A signal for next time: what in a future question should remind you of this. "If I see X, I'll do Y."
Copying a worked solution feels like understanding without checking it, which is why the third part is in your own words. If you can't explain the right method in a sentence or two, label the entry a knowledge gap and go back to the topic before you log it.
Sample entries
| Subject | Question in brief | Why it went wrong | The right way | Signal for next time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Algebra | Solve x² = 9x | Misconception: divided both sides by x and lost a root | Move everything to one side: x(x − 9) = 0, so x = 0 or x = 9 | Never divide by an expression that could be zero; factor instead |
| Chemistry | Moles in 10 g of NaOH | Careless slip: used 23 g/mol, the mass of Na alone | Na 23 + O 16 + H 1 = 40 g/mol, so 10 ÷ 40 = 0.25 mol | Write the molar mass sum out, one element per line |
| Spanish | "Yesterday I went to the beach" | Knowledge gap: used the imperfect iba | One completed action at a set time takes the preterite: Ayer fui a la playa | "Ayer" and a finished event point to the preterite |
| Reading | Main idea of a passage | Misreading: picked a detail that is true but isn't the main point | The main idea covers the whole passage; test each option against every paragraph | An option that fits only one paragraph is a detail |
| History | Main cause of an event | Timing: guessed in the last minute | I knew it; I had spent four minutes on an earlier question | Skip after about 90 seconds, mark it, come back |
Paper or digital?
Pick the one you will actually open. A paper notebook with a section per subject is quick to write in, and a spreadsheet or notes app lets you filter by type and topic. Photos help with diagrams, but write the four parts next to them, or the log turns into a photo album you never reopen.
Keep it small. Log the mistakes you could make again: misconceptions, knowledge gaps and your recurring slips. A one-off typo on a question you will never see again needs only a tally mark.
A review routine after every practice test
- On the same day, check your answers. Before you open any solution, give each wrong and blank question a few more minutes on your own.
- Read the solutions and sort each mistake by type. Write log entries for the ones worth keeping and redo each of those questions once without the solution.
- Go through the questions you got right with a "?" next to them and make sure you can explain each answer.
- One to three days later, redo the logged questions from scratch, without notes. Anything you miss goes back to the top of the list.
- About a week later, redo them again, mixed with new questions on the same topics so you also have to recognize which method each one needs.
- Before the next practice test, read your "signals for next time" and pick one or two habits to practice, such as underlining "not".
When you get a question right on three separate days, take it out of rotation. This is close to what Katherine Rawson, John Dunlosky and Sharon Sciartelli (2013) call successive relearning: practice until you get it right, then come back in later sessions and get it right again. In an introductory psychology course, students who practiced key concepts this way did better on the course exams and remembered more later than with their usual studying.
Blank questions belong in the review. A blank means you either didn't know where to start or ran out of time, and both show up in the table above. Leaving them out hides your biggest gaps.
As a rough guide (not a research figure), plan at least half as long for the review as for the test itself. After a two-hour mock exam, ten minutes of checking the score is too little.
A sample week around one mock exam
| Day | What to do | About |
|---|---|---|
| Saturday | Full mock exam, timed, phone in another room | Exam length |
| Saturday, later in the day | Retry, sort and log the mistakes, redo the logged questions once | 1–1.5 h |
| Monday | 15–20 questions on the topic with the most knowledge gaps | 45 min |
| Tuesday | Redo the logged questions from scratch | 30 min |
| Thursday | Practice the skip rule on a timed set of 20 questions | 30 min |
| Next Saturday | Redo the logged questions mixed with new ones, then the next mock | 30 min + exam |
The times are only examples. Fit the review blocks into your weekly study schedule like any other subject, and use time blocking to place them within the day.
Track the pattern, not just the score
Total scores jump around from test to test, because each test covers different topics, some papers are harder and some days you are tired. Look at the trend across several tests, and at where the points go.
After each test, count the questions you lost by type. Here is an example from three 60-question practice tests:
| Test | Knowledge gap | Misconception | Misreading | Careless slip | Timing | Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 39 of 60 |
| 2 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 43 of 60 |
| 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 48 of 60 |
Knowledge gaps and timing losses went down here, so the topic work and the skip rule are doing their job. Careless slips stayed flat, so they are the next target: maybe a check step at the end of each calculation, or writing the units on every line.
A simple line chart of your scores helps, especially with the average of your last three tests on it, because one bad test is not a trend. If the total stops rising for several tests, look at the type counts before you change your whole plan. Usually one type is holding you back.
Wrong-answer penalties and guessing
Whether you should guess depends on your exam's rules, and exams differ. Two examples from official sources:
- For the SAT, the College Board's page on how scores are calculated says that for most students who are trying their best on every question, it is better to guess than leave a question blank, especially if they can eliminate one or two answer choices first.
- For Türkiye's university entrance exam (YKS), the 2026 guide from ÖSYM says the raw score on each test is the number of correct answers minus a quarter of the number of wrong answers. Four wrong answers cancel one right answer.
For any other exam, read the scoring section of the official guide for your year, because rules can change between years.
Under a penalty like YKS's, the math of guessing changes. With five answer choices and four wrong answers canceling one right one, a blind guess gains nothing on average. Once you can rule out even one choice, a guess comes out slightly ahead on average. In your review, count your marked guesses: how many were blind, how many came after you had ruled out choices, and how many of each were right. That tells you whether your guessing rule works for you. Without a penalty, a blank is simply a lost point, so practice getting to every question.
Common mistakes when reviewing practice tests
- Reading the right answer and moving on. It feels like learning, but nothing is tested. Try the question again first, then read.
- Only reviewing wrong answers. Blanks and lucky guesses hide gaps too.
- Calling everything "careless". If it happens on every test, it is a pattern with a fix.
- Copying the solution word for word into the log. Explain it in your own words or you won't notice what you still don't understand.
- Keeping a log you never reopen. Put the redo days in your plan, the same as homework.
- Taking practice test after practice test without reviewing them. If you don't have time to review, take fewer tests.
- Deciding how you're doing from one score. Look at the average and at the mistake types.
If practice tests leave you anxious, see how to deal with exam stress for techniques you can rehearse during a mock. Mistakes on a practice test cost you nothing, and they show you what to work on before the exam that counts.
FAQ
How do you review a practice test?
Within 24 hours, retry each wrong and blank question before you read the solution. Then sort every mistake by cause, log the ones you could repeat in your own words, and redo those questions one to three days later and again about a week later.
What should I write in a mistake log?
Four things: the question in brief, why you got it wrong, the right way in your own words and a signal for next time. Leave out one-off typos and log the mistakes you could make again.
How often should I take full practice tests?
Research doesn't give a single number. Take them only as often as you can review each one properly; one reviewed mock teaches you more than three unreviewed ones. As the exam gets closer you can take them closer together, as long as each one still gets its review.
Should I redo the same questions or do new ones?
Both. Redoing the same question from scratch checks whether the fix stuck. New questions on the same topic check whether you learned the method, because remembering one question's answer doesn't mean you can solve the next one.
Why do I keep making careless mistakes?
Usually because the same kind of slip repeats: signs, units, copying numbers, skipping "not". Count them by kind in your log, add one check step aimed at your most common slip and practice it on timed sets. Rushing because of time pressure is a timing problem, so work on pacing too.
Is it bad to get lots of questions wrong on practice tests?
No. Kornell and colleagues (2009) found that even failed attempts helped later learning once people saw the answer, and Metcalfe's 2017 review recommends making and correcting errors in low-stakes practice before a high-stakes exam. What matters is that every mistake gets reviewed.
Sources and further reading
- Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249–255.
- Yang, C., Luo, L., Vadillo, M. A., Yu, R., & Shanks, D. R. (2021). Testing (quizzing) boosts classroom learning: A systematic and meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin, 147(4), 399–435.
- Kornell, N., Hays, M. J., & Bjork, R. A. (2009). Unsuccessful retrieval attempts enhance subsequent learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 35(4), 989–998.
- Butterfield, B., & Metcalfe, J. (2001). Errors committed with high confidence are hypercorrected. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 27(6), 1491–1494.
- Metcalfe, J. (2017). Learning from errors. Annual Review of Psychology, 68, 465–489.
- Butler, A. C., Karpicke, J. D., & Roediger, H. L. (2008). Correcting a metacognitive error: Feedback increases retention of low-confidence correct responses. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 34(4), 918–928.
- Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112.
- Wisniewski, B., Zierer, K., & Hattie, J. (2020). The power of feedback revisited: A meta-analysis of educational feedback research. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, 3087.
- Rawson, K. A., Dunlosky, J., & Sciartelli, S. M. (2013). The power of successive relearning: Improving performance on course exams and long-term retention. Educational Psychology Review, 25(4), 523–548.
- Soicher, R. N., & Gurung, R. A. R. (2017). Do exam wrappers increase metacognition and performance? A single course intervention. Psychology Learning & Teaching, 16(1), 64–73.
- College Board: How Are Scores Calculated?
- ÖSYM: 2026 Yükseköğretim Kurumları Sınavı (YKS) Kılavuzu
Make your next study session count
Study Buddy Cat turns every verified minute of focus into food for your cat. No account or paywall to start, no ads, and when you take a break, your cat waits for you.