# Should You Study With Music? Lyrics, Lo-Fi and White Noise

> What research says about studying with music: why lyrics hurt reading, when lo-fi or white noise is fine, and how to choose a sound for each kind of task.

By the Study Buddy Cat team · Published: 2026-10-28 · 12 min read · Focus  
URL: https://studybuddycat.com/en/blog/study-music-white-noise/

## In short

- Songs with lyrics you can understand make reading and writing harder, even when you love the song: the words compete with the words on the page.
- Instrumental music at a calm tempo and low volume, steady rain or café noise, and plain white, pink or brown noise get in the way much less, but for hard reading, silence usually still gives the highest scores.
- Match the sound to the task, keep the volume low, and test it for a week by checking how much you finished, not how it felt.

Music can help you study, but not all music and not for every task. The clearest finding in the research is about **lyrics**: songs with words you understand make reading, writing and memorizing harder, and liking the song doesn't fix that. **Instrumental music** at a calm tempo and low volume, **steady background sounds** like rain or a café, and **white, pink or brown noise** get in the way much less. For the hardest reading, silence still tends to come out on top.

So the useful question is not "music or no music" but "which sound for which task". Reading a dense chapter and solving a page of routine math problems put very different demands on your brain, and the right sound for one can be the wrong sound for the other.

The short version: save songs with lyrics for breaks and easy tasks, use quiet instrumental music or steady ambient sound when you need to block out a noisy room, and keep the volume low enough that you could still hear someone say your name.

## Which sound for which task

This table sums up the evidence below. Treat it as a starting point, then test it on yourself.

| Task | Sounds that usually work | Sounds to avoid |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Reading a textbook, essays, reading comprehension | Silence, steady rain or white noise at low volume | Songs with lyrics in a language you know, podcasts, TV |
| Writing (essays, summaries, notes) | Silence, calm instrumental music | Lyrics, talk radio, music you sing along to |
| Memorizing lists, vocabulary, formulas | Silence or steady noise | Any changing sound: speech, melodies with clear notes |
| Practice problems you already know how to solve | Instrumental music, lo-fi, café sound | Very fast or very loud music |
| Copying, coloring maps, organizing notes | Almost anything, including music you like | Volume high enough to tire your ears |
| Brainstorming, planning a project | Light café-level background noise | Loud noise |

## Why lyrics get in the way

Your working memory, the mental space where you hold a sentence while you make sense of it, doesn't have a door it can close to sound. Speech gets in whether you want it to or not.

Back in 1982, Pierre Salamé and Alan Baddeley showed that people remembered short lists of digits less well when someone was speaking in the background, even though they were told to ignore it. Later work by Dylan Jones and William Macken (1993) found that it isn't only words: any sound that keeps changing from one moment to the next, such as a melody of distinct tones, disrupts memory for the order of things. A steady, unchanging sound does much less. Researchers call this the *irrelevant sound effect*.

Reading adds a second problem. When you read, you process meaning, and lyrics carry meaning too. Your brain has to keep pushing the song's words aside to follow the text, and that costs effort.

The most direct test with students is a study by Nick Perham and Harriet Currie (2014). Thirty university students answered reading comprehension questions from SAT practice tests in four conditions: quiet, lyrical music they liked, lyrical music they disliked, and instrumental music. Results:

- Scores were highest in quiet and with instrumental music, and those two were about the same.
- Lyrical music hurt comprehension, and **music the students liked hurt it as much as music they disliked**.
- The students themselves felt the lyrical music was distracting, yet many people still assume their favorite playlist helps them read.

A larger picture comes from a 2018 meta-analysis by Martin Vasilev, Julie Kirkby and Bernhard Angele, which pooled 65 studies on sound during reading. Noise, speech and music all had a small but reliable negative effect on reading. Intelligible speech and music with lyrics caused the most disruption, and the effect was about the same in children and adults.

> **If you can't give up lyrics**
>
> Use songs with lyrics for tasks that need little language: drawing diagrams, sorting notes, routine arithmetic, cleaning your desk before a session. Switch to instrumental music or silence when you open the textbook.

## Instrumental music, lo-fi and classical

Taking the words away removes the biggest problem, but music still has features that matter.

- **Tempo and volume.** William Forde Thompson, Glenn Schellenberg and Adriana Letnic (2012) had students read while instrumental music played slow or fast, soft or loud. Comprehension dropped clearly only when the music was both fast and loud. Slow or soft versions caused little harm.
- **Overall effect.** A meta-analysis by Juliane Kämpfe and colleagues (2011) found that background music, across many kinds of tasks, had close to no overall effect, but small negative effects on reading and memory. Music isn't a hidden study booster, and it isn't a disaster either.
- **Lo-fi.** Research on lo-fi itself is still thin. In a 2023 study by Alessandra Souza and Luís Carlos Leal Barbosa, college students did memory, reading and arithmetic tasks in silence, with lo-fi hip-hop or with songs with lyrics: lo-fi neither clearly helped nor clearly hurt, while the songs with lyrics hurt memory and reading comprehension. That fits what the wider research favors: no lyrics, moderate tempo, soft and repetitive. Watch for tracks with spoken samples or vocals, which bring the lyrics problem back.
- **Classical.** Classical music isn't automatically calm: a fast, loud orchestral piece changes constantly. A slow piano piece is closer to the lo-fi profile than a symphony finale.

Many students find familiar instrumental music easier to ignore than something new, which keeps pulling at their attention. If a track makes you want to listen, it's the wrong track for studying.

## Music before you study is a different story

The famous *Mozart effect* came from a short 1993 paper in *Nature* by Frances Rauscher and colleagues: students who listened to ten minutes of a Mozart sonata did better on a spatial task right afterwards. The idea that classical music makes you smarter spread quickly. It didn't hold up. A meta-analysis by Jakob Pietschnig, Martin Voracek and Anton Formann (2010), covering about 40 studies and over 3,000 people, found little evidence for a specific Mozart effect.

What did hold up is simpler. Thompson, Schellenberg and Gabriela Husain (2001) showed that music which lifts your mood and energy can briefly improve performance on a task that follows it, and that sad, slow music doesn't. The effect comes from mood and arousal, not from Mozart.

That gives you a useful split:

- **Before a session or during a break:** play whatever music you love, lyrics included. It can lift your mood and help you get started.
- **During the session:** switch to the sound that suits the task, or to silence.

This is also why a short break with your favorite song works better than keeping it on in the background. For what to do in breaks, see [study break ideas](https://studybuddycat.com/en/blog/study-break-ideas/).

## White, pink and brown noise

These are steady hissing or rushing sounds that differ only in how their energy is spread across pitches:

- **White noise** has equal energy at every frequency and sounds like a bright hiss, like an untuned radio.
- **Pink noise** has less energy in the high frequencies and sounds softer, closer to steady rain.
- **Brown noise** drops off even more and sounds like a low rumble, close to a waterfall or the inside of a plane.

Their main job is **masking**: a steady sound covers unpredictable ones, such as conversations, traffic or a sibling's video, which are exactly the changing sounds that break concentration. If your room is noisy, steady noise at a low volume can be much less distracting than the room itself.

Do they improve focus by themselves? The strongest evidence so far comes from a 2024 meta-analysis led by Joel Nigg. In children and young adults with ADHD or high levels of attention problems (13 studies, 335 participants), white or pink noise gave a small but statistically significant improvement in task performance. In comparison groups without attention problems, the same noise slightly *worsened* performance. No studies of brown noise met the criteria at all, so the claims about brown noise online are ahead of the research.

The practical reading:

- If you struggle a lot with attention, steady noise is worth a fair test. It's not a treatment, and it doesn't replace advice from a doctor or specialist.
- If you don't, use noise mainly to mask a noisy room, not as a focus booster.
- Whichever color you pick, the right one is the one you can stop noticing after a few minutes. Many people find brown or pink noise easier on the ears than white.

## Rain, café and nature sounds

Rain, wind, waves and a distant café are close to colored noise: they vary a little, but not in a way that pulls at your attention. They also feel more pleasant to many people than pure noise, which makes it easier to keep them on for a whole session.

Café sound gets special attention because of a 2012 study by Ravi Mehta, Rui Zhu and Amar Cheema. Across five experiments, a moderate level of background noise (about 70 decibels, a mix of cafeteria chatter, traffic and distant construction) led to better performance on creative tasks than a quiet 50 decibels, while a loud 85 decibels made performance worse. The authors explain it as a mild distraction that pushes you toward more abstract thinking. Note what was measured: creativity tasks, such as finding a word that links three others, not reading or memorizing. A café recording suits brainstorming an essay plan better than learning a list of dates.

One detail matters for café sounds: you want a general murmur, not conversations you can follow. As soon as you can make out words, you're back to the lyrics problem.

## Volume and headphones

Low volume is easier on both your attention and your hearing. The World Health Organization and the International Telecommunication Union set a safe listening standard in 2019. For adults, it uses a weekly sound allowance equal to 80 decibels for 40 hours. Louder listening uses up the allowance much faster. Long study days with headphones add up quickly.

Simple rules that keep you well within it:

- Set the volume so you can still hear someone in the room say your name.
- If you can't hear your own pen on the paper, it's probably too loud for reading.
- In a noisy place, noise-canceling headphones let you keep the volume lower instead of turning it up to drown out the room.
- Take your headphones off in breaks. Your ears get a rest, and you notice if you'd been turning the sound up without realizing.
- Use your phone's built-in hearing or headphone safety settings if it has them.

## Binaural beats and "focus frequencies"

Binaural beats play two slightly different tones, one in each ear, and your brain hears a slow beat at the difference between them. Many videos promise that a given beat frequency will "tune" your brainwaves for focus.

A 2023 systematic review by Ruth Maria Ingendoh, Ella Posny and Angela Heine looked at studies that measured brain activity during binaural beats. Of 14 studies, five found results in line with that tuning idea, eight found results that contradicted it, and one was mixed. The methods differed so much that the authors called for standardized research before drawing conclusions. If you like binaural beat tracks as a calm background, there's no reason to stop, but don't expect them to do more than any other quiet, steady sound.

## Find your own study sound in one week

Research describes averages; you're one person with one room and one set of habits. A simple test settles it better than another hour of searching for the perfect playlist.

1. Pick one recurring task, such as 30 minutes of reading or a set of practice problems.
2. Do it on different days with silence, with steady ambient sound, and with instrumental music, all at low volume.
3. After each session, write down how much you finished and how many times you got distracted, not just how pleasant it felt.
4. Compare at the end of the week and keep the winner for that kind of task.
5. Choose your sound before you start the timer, so you don't spend the session skipping tracks.

The last step matters more than it looks. Choosing music *during* the session is one of the easiest ways to drift to your phone. For more on that, see [how to stop using your phone while studying](https://studybuddycat.com/en/blog/stop-using-phone-while-studying/) and [how to focus while studying](https://studybuddycat.com/en/blog/how-to-focus-while-studying/).

> **Ambient sounds in Study Buddy Cat**
>
> Study Buddy Cat has 12 ambient sounds built into the focus timer: soft rain, café, fireplace, forest, ocean, wind, night, thunder, white, pink and brown noise, and your cat's purring. In Pomodoro mode you can pick one sound for focus blocks and another for breaks, for example rain while you work and purring while you rest. Each sound downloads once the first time you choose it and then plays offline, fades in and out gently, and has an adjustable volume. Sound is off unless you turn it on, and every verified focus minute is 1 food for your cat.
>
> [Google Play](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.studybuddy.study_buddy_cat) · [App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/study-buddy-cat-focus-timer/id6761442024) · [Get the app](https://studybuddycat.com/app)

## Frequently asked questions

### Is it bad to study with music?

Not in general. It depends on the music and the task. Songs with lyrics make reading, writing and memorizing harder for most people. Calm instrumental music at low volume does little harm on many tasks, and music you love can help as a warm-up or a break.

### Is lo-fi good for studying?

It fits what the research favors: no lyrics, moderate tempo, soft and repetitive. A 2023 study that tested lo-fi tracks found they neither clearly helped nor clearly hurt compared with silence. Avoid tracks with vocal samples, keep the volume low, and use silence for your hardest reading if you notice you read better without it.

### Is brown noise better than white noise for studying?

There's no evidence yet that one color works better: a 2024 meta-analysis found no qualifying studies of brown noise at all, and the benefits it found for white and pink noise were in people with attention problems. Pick the color you can stop noticing. Many people find brown or pink noise softer than white.

### Does classical music make you smarter?

No. The original Mozart effect was a short-lived improvement on one spatial task, and a large meta-analysis found little evidence for it. Music that lifts your mood can give a brief boost before a task, and that works with any music you enjoy.

### Can I listen to songs in a language I don't understand?

They're less disruptive for reading than songs in your own language, because you can't follow the meaning. But the melody and voice still change constantly, so they can still get in the way of memorizing. If you use them, keep them for practice problems rather than vocabulary or formulas.

### Should I practice in silence before an exam?

Exam halls are usually quiet, so it makes sense to do at least your full practice tests in silence. That way the conditions on exam day feel familiar, and you know you can work without your usual sound.

## Sources and further reading

1. Salamé, P., & Baddeley, A. (1982). Disruption of short-term memory by unattended speech: Implications for the structure of working memory. *Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior*, 21(2), 150–164.
2. Jones, D. M., & Macken, W. J. (1993). Irrelevant tones produce an irrelevant speech effect: Implications for phonological coding in working memory. *Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition*, 19(2), 369–381.
3. Perham, N., & Currie, H. (2014). Does listening to preferred music improve reading comprehension performance? *Applied Cognitive Psychology*, 28(2), 279–284.
4. Vasilev, M. R., Kirkby, J. A., & Angele, B. (2018). Auditory distraction during reading: A Bayesian meta-analysis of a continuing controversy. *Perspectives on Psychological Science*, 13(5), 567–597.
5. Kämpfe, J., Sedlmeier, P., & Renkewitz, F. (2011). The impact of background music on adult listeners: A meta-analysis. *Psychology of Music*, 39(4), 424–448.
6. Thompson, W. F., Schellenberg, E. G., & Letnic, A. K. (2012). Fast and loud background music disrupts reading comprehension. *Psychology of Music*, 40(6), 700–708.
7. Souza, A. S., & Leal Barbosa, L. C. (2023). Should we turn off the music? Music with lyrics interferes with cognitive tasks. *Journal of Cognition*, 6(1), 24.
8. Rauscher, F. H., Shaw, G. L., & Ky, K. N. (1993). Music and spatial task performance. *Nature*, 365(6447), 611.
9. Thompson, W. F., Schellenberg, E. G., & Husain, G. (2001). Arousal, mood, and the Mozart effect. *Psychological Science*, 12(3), 248–251.
10. Pietschnig, J., Voracek, M., & Formann, A. K. (2010). Mozart effect–Shmozart effect: A meta-analysis. *Intelligence*, 38(3), 314–323.
11. Mehta, R., Zhu, R., & Cheema, A. (2012). Is noise always bad? Exploring the effects of ambient noise on creative cognition. *Journal of Consumer Research*, 39(4), 784–799.
12. Nigg, J. T., Bruton, A., Kozlowski, M. B., Johnstone, J. M., & Karalunas, S. L. (2024). Systematic review and meta-analysis: Do white noise or pink noise help with task performance in youth with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder or with elevated attention problems? *Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry*, 63(8), 778–788.
13. Ingendoh, R. M., Posny, E. S., & Heine, A. (2023). Binaural beats to entrain the brain? A systematic review of the effects of binaural beat stimulation on brain oscillatory activity, and the implications for psychological research and intervention. *PLOS ONE*, 18(5), e0286023.
14. World Health Organization & International Telecommunication Union. (2019). *Safe listening devices and systems: A WHO-ITU standard*. World Health Organization.

---

**Make your next study session count.** Study Buddy Cat turns every verified minute of focus into food for your cat. No account or paywall to start, no ads, and when you take a break, your cat waits for you. [Get the app](https://studybuddycat.com/app)

Language: [Türkçe](https://studybuddycat.com/tr/blog/ders-calisirken-muzik-dinlemek/) · [Deutsch](https://studybuddycat.com/de/blog/musik-zum-lernen/) · [Español](https://studybuddycat.com/es/blog/musica-para-estudiar/) · [Français](https://studybuddycat.com/fr/blog/musique-pour-reviser/) · [Italiano](https://studybuddycat.com/it/blog/musica-per-studiare/) · [Português](https://studybuddycat.com/pt/blog/musica-para-estudar/) · [Русский](https://studybuddycat.com/ru/blog/muzyka-dlya-ucheby/) · [العربية](https://studybuddycat.com/ar/blog/study-music-white-noise/) · [اردو](https://studybuddycat.com/ur/blog/study-music-white-noise/) · [हिन्दी](https://studybuddycat.com/hi/blog/study-music-white-noise/) · [বাংলা](https://studybuddycat.com/bn/blog/study-music-white-noise/) · [简体中文](https://studybuddycat.com/zh-hans/blog/study-music-white-noise/)
